2011 Saab 9-5 Aero XWD Sedan

Fifty grand? I realize that's the basic point for the German competition in this segment (BMW 5-series, Audi A6, Mercedes-Benz E-class), but this Saab 9-5 Aero certainly doesn't feel like $52,530 worth of automobile. Nor does it feel like a legitimate rival to those aforementioned Germans, not to mention all the excellent mid-size luxury cars on the market today. Another weakness is that this 9-5's Saab-y quirkiness feels forced, and its GM heritage is too evident for my liking.

Nonetheless, the 9-5 drives and steers well, and although the engine displayed distracting turbo lag during my time in the car, its powertrain was very peppy. The so-called DriveSense System made a noticeable difference when I toggled among comfort, intelligent, and sport modes, whereas some competitors' similar systems don't seem to make a difference in a car's ride and handling. Speaking of comfort, the 9-5 offers a lot of it, and the rear seats are very spacious. The eight-inch touch screen is nice and large, too.

Unlike Mr. Zenlea, I think the 9-5 looks strangely stretched from the rear-three-quarter angle. The turbinelike wheels are quite cool, though.
- Rusty Blackwell, Copy Editor

My colleagues have said it all about this highly competent new Saab that ultimately lacks the appeal that would make me, at least, sign a sales contract for a rather breathtaking $52,530. I especially like David Zenlea's analysis. This is a good car, even a very good car, and I agree with Zenlea that it's a very good-looking car. But, boy, I hope Jason Castriota, the American-born automotive designer who cut his teeth at Pininfarina and who is now the chief designer at Saab, is working overtime on a new interior design philosophy that will be at once Saab and modern.
- Joe DeMatio, Deputy Editor

BikeDude
"but does that make any sense without a physical key?"When you start your car, there are several activities that frequently takes place:1) Check parking brake2) Fiddle with the transmission3) Fiddle with the ignitionGuess what... Having these grouped together in one spot makes perfect sense."All-wheel drive and a set of winter tires made the 9-5 a delight to drive on the snowy country roads near my in-laws' house. "I bet the FWD version would be just as competent on snow and ice.With a 9-5 (or any Saab) I am able to pass a great many cars when the winter turns a bit "ugly". When they have only plowed one lane of the highway, it doesn't matter that I am in the lane with 3-5 inches of snow and the other cars are in the lane where all the snow has been removed; I am still passing them, often going faster than 65 mph.The limit is not the car, but rather how much I am willing to break the legal speed limit.German cars rarely look good in the snow or on ice. The word "Bambi" springs to mind.

New Car Research

our instagram

get Automobile Magazine

Subscribe to the magazine and save up to 84% off the newsstand price

subscribe

new cars

Read Related Articles

TO TOP