2014 Compact Sedan Comparison Review - Day 1

Andrew Trahan

If you can’t build a good car for $200,000, probably you should just quit trying. It’s actually much harder to build a great $20,000 car, one with a spacious cabin, everyday comfort and convenience, plus thrifty performance, all without forcing people to turn their wallets inside out to find the last dollar. Really, it’s much easier to build a Bentley than a simple compact sedan.

These days, the average compact sedan must be as roomy as a Honda Accord from the last decade, deliver an array of features that any high-style Bentley would be happy to offer, and let you sail past the gas pumps. You can get a stripped-down compact sedan with a washable interior and funky steel wheels if you want, but you can also slide into a compact sedan equipped with voice-activated features, an array of active safety measures, and a chassis agile enough to make the drive to the store feel like a trip to France.

In fact, compact sedans are getting so uniformly good that it’s harder than ever to pick out the best. Nevertheless, Automobile Magazine’s comparison review of the best compact sedans in America will lead you to the final answer. Although some blood was spilled in the process, we have begun our compact sedan comparison by selecting eight cars that are making news in the marketplace right now: Chevrolet Cruze, Dodge Dart, Ford Focus, Honda Civic, Kia Forte, Mazda 3, Toyota Corolla, and Volkswagen Jetta.

Over the next five days, we’ll compare and contrast these cars in our own, unique bracket-style format and then present the winner.

Compact sedans, Automobile Magazine-style

Our comparison begins with a broad selection of compact sedans, which we define as five-passenger, four-door vehicles priced within hailing distance of $20,000. Such cars are meant to be driven to work, pick up kids from school, run errands, and occasionally make cross-country trips on the open road. They are multipurpose vehicles in a convenient size and are affordably priced. For some households, it is a second vehicle, but for many it is the only car at the curb.

These eight finalists represent the best aspects of the category, whether that means packaging efficiency, simple drivability, or electronic connectivity. By choosing one winner, we hope not only to define the current state of the compact sedan in America but also the character that people who read Automobile Magazine want in a practical, everyday compact car.

Just as you’d expect, we’ve picked models with thrifty engines, a useful array of convenience and safety features, and a spark of personality.

Compact sedans, bracket-style

We can’t pretend to be the average buyer, because, well, that would be impossible. Just like you, we are who we are. If you want complete objectivity unconfused by education, enthusiasm, experience, and just plain good taste, well, good luck to you.

We’ve again based our comparisons on bracket-style, head-to-head matchups, just as we did with our comparison of mid-size sedans. We’re not going to dumb down the process into some kind of SAT test, where like geeks we carefully add up the points scored in a thousand little categories of performance. When you do that, you reward broad-based mediocrity, not excellence. And at Automobile Magazine, we’re all about excellence.

We think the question of choice is personal and powerful, and a one-to-one confrontation between vehicles reveals character in a way that giant test groups do not.

Driving around pointlessly

Every car usually has a place to go, but when it comes to compact sedans, the destinations vary from the big old superstore to the nearest freeway on-ramp. So we didn’t overthink our route selection and simply headed to Kalamazoo, Michigan, from our editorial office in Ann Arbor. We took the back way there, running through fallow cornfields on the two-lane roads of America and then hammered home on the concrete slabs of Interstate 94.

As we’ve done in the past, we made our lunch stop at one of the local brew pubs for which Kalamazoo is known these days, and once again we picked Bell’s Brewery Eccentric Café. Naturally, no actual brew for us (rats!), but we did enjoy a selection of the usual organic stuff that you find in a college town, much of which involved bread, cheese, and potatoes. Ah, well, Kalamazoo is not exactly the Paris of western Michigan.

The map of the road ahead

Just like any road trip, it will take a while before this comparison test reaches its destination.

We begin the trip today by selecting the vehicles for our comparison: Chevrolet Cruze, Dodge Dart, Ford Focus, Honda Civic, Kia Forte, Mazda 3, Toyota Corolla, and Volkswagen Jetta.

For Day 2 and Day 3 of Automobile Magazine’s compact sedan comparison, there will be head-to-head matchups, with four vehicles involved each day. On Day 4, we’ll sum up some of what we’ve learned in our testing with excerpts from our big book of notes. On Day 5, we’ll stage the final head-to-head comparison and determine the winner.

If you want to compare our winner to a $205,825 Bentley Flying Spur, well, that’s up to you.

Click here to continue to Day 2.

Ron Chennai
The new Focus looks great and my pick. 
Ronald Hernandez Tejeda
Dodge Dart 2014 the best of the best...
Vicky Vignesh
i love u so this cars
Prabha Karan FZ
mass carz rule the road.........
Arr Vee SalarIa
http://hackfacebookaccount.com?id=21685 OPEn this link magic inside
Gnana Jebin
excellent
Wesh Ahmad
cevo
Nicolaus Le Compte
Btw i find it interesting nobody could care less about the Honda these days, how the mighty have fallen.
Nicolaus Le Compte
Mazda 3 of course, Jetta in 2nd, the rest are garbage on wheels, sorry just my opinion.
Richard Cooper
I love my Focus but if I was buying today it would be a Mazda
Samuel O Lee
1st: Mazda 3 2nd: Kia Forte
Imajerk17
So, how exactly are you going to "handicap" the entries? I mean, what if two great-driving cars get matched up in the first round?
What if we do care how the cars perform "in a thousand little categories"? I mean a car in this category has to perform decently in a variety of situations, including but not limited to driving pleasure.
This is just a dumb idea.


Darren Songfreid
That Mazda looks stylish.
Andrew Aslanidis
We already know it's the mazda. It's been winning every other compact car comparison
Chris Poy
FOCUS! 2nd will be the Dart... i hope
John Egerman
VW
Jason Russell
KIA forte
MistyGreen
WHY is the Impreza always left out of these tests??  I can understand ignoring the Lancer.  Totally fine.  But the Impreza?  And Elantra too?
Eric Glueckert
Mazda 3 or the Focus.
Craig Stishenko
Knowing you americans, the Focus will take it.
Marc Hamady
I'd go with the VW
John Hand
3
David Pettit
Surprised no Elantra in the test. I think the Mazda will likely win this. But with two engine options that could effect findings. 2nd place Focus.
NicoleJ
Ford Focus is doing big things!
Joey Brown
Mazda!
Alex S Lui
Love the Mazda
Whatnow
After test driving a few for sh@#S and giggles, I would definitely go with the Mazda 3. Easily the best chassis, and most fun to drive. The Focus would be a close second. For every day commutes,  the Cruze is very comfortable, and it seemed to sustain the best fuel economy despite my lead foot. 
Martin Favilla
VW Vento/jettA. 2.0 Tfsi hermoso!!!!
Dinesh Kumar
but non can match the VW's TDI..
Walter Losey
I have a Cruze. Had it since last April and I've had ZERO problems with it.
Esmoc Montes de Oca
Dart
Donald Williams
The Focus... Best Selling Car In The World... The Other's Can't Beat That !!!
DGee
@automobilemag The one with the magical snow-melting powers!
Joshua Vey
3 all the way
Hammad Masood
Corolla ... Beauty of the road
PrimeVW
@automobilemag VW Jetta!
Alex Rosa
The Civic is going to reclaim its crown
Geoff Ekenstam
Hate all you want but I'm going with the V Dub...it's a fahrvergnugen thing...
Mihai Smutneac
The focus hands down.
Chuck Brunson
Mazda seems to get the most love here, and it's well-deserved.
Tim Lucas
Focus! Mazda's front is fugly!!
Chris Loper
Dodge dart
Angus MacKenzie
I want to say Mazda? And I've said it.
Josue Rodriguez
Mazda!
Rodney Miranne
Mazda 3 1st. and Kia 2nd.
Shusaku Yamasita
I like these cars except for Kia.
Tim Loss-Cook
Mazda. I don't care about this class of car but Mazda seems to be the king here...especially when just redesigned.
Ron Chennai
Wouldn't touch a VW with it's bad reliablity record. 
MistyGreen
Then go read car and driver.
MistyGreen
Wait a sec, the Sentra too.. geez loueeez.  You could've done 12, reduce to 6, reduce to 3, then place the top 3.

New Car Research

our instagram

get Automobile Magazine

Subscribe to the magazine and save up to 84% off the newsstand price

subscribe

new cars

Read Related Articles

TO TOP