First Drive: 2012 BMW 528i Four-Cylinder

BMW is among the growing number of automakers that thinks it's time to stop judging engines by how many cylinders they have. They're probably right - in terms of output, for sure: the best modern turbocharged engines can easily make more power than their predecessors with twice the cylinder count. More boost is more power -- that's the easy part.

The hard part is making the package work in terms of refinement. Downsizing from a V-8 to a straight-six, for example, is a painless exercise: in-line sixes are just as smooth as V-8s. But what about going from a straight-six, the holy grail of refinement, to a four-banger -- the roughest of the bunch?

BMW started that gamble last month when the company let us drive its Z4 sDrive28i -- the first North American application of the N20-series 2.0-liter turbo four-cylinder. We came away mighty impressed but remained a little concerned that in less sporty, more luxurious applications like the 5-series, the N20 might be a little too rough. BMW officials assured us that the N20 would receive a revised NVH package in the 5-series, and as it turns out, they didn't lie.

We had an opportunity to slide behind the wheel of a 528i wagon equipped with the N20. In this application, the N20 is rated at 245 hp and 258 lb-ft. Bolted to an eight-speed automatic and thrown under the wagon's hood, the engine is powerful enough for a 6.3-second run to 62 mph, according to BMW. Top speed is electronically limited to 155 mph. We'll let those numbers speak for themselves.

More important, like we mentioned above, is what the engine is like. The N20 is phenomenally quiet and refined at low rpm. The standard start/stop works so well, in combination with an engine that's so quiet and smooth (even in gear with the air conditioning engaged) that you sometimes need to look at the tachometer to see if it's running.

The 528i isn't all about isolation, either. Refinement is more the word, because once the revs start climbing, you can very clearly hear the engine. What you hear, though, is all sweetness and light until about 6000 rpm: up until that point, the sound is unmistakably four-cylinder, just with all the bad bits removed. It sounds throaty, purposeful, and completely and totally in line with what the buyer of a base-model BMW 5-series would expect.

Is the new, downsized, four-cylinder BMW 528i a home run? Almost -- let's call it a triple. Even though the turbo is responsive enough in normal driving that you don't even notice its existence (oh, but you do hear lots of delicious turbo sounds with the windows down) you can occasionally catch the entire powertrain sleeping. Cruising along, you tip into the throttle and the engine and transmission start to fight about whose turn it is to work. Eventually, they both do: you get a downshift and lots of power, but the wait is a good bit longer than you'd expect. That, combined with fairly conservative throttle mapping (in Comfort mode; it's better in Sport) means the 528i feels a tad lazy around town.

Of course, this is a small engine pushing around quite a large sedan. Or, in the case of our particular test car, a large, stunningly beautiful station wagon. Oh, how we hope BMW will bring the 5-series Touring back to the United States. It's even better looking than the sedan and provides tons of extra usability with absolutely zero drawbacks. And it's more than quick enough with the 2.0-liter, as will be the sedan.

Final EPA numbers aren't in, but BMW says to expect a significant improvement over the 528i's already stunning fuel economy numbers. (The 528i sedan with the normally aspirated 3.0-liter six already achieves 32 mpg on EPA highway testing.) Expect that number to improve slightly with more of a gain on the 22-mpg EPA city number.

With significantly more torque (over a far larger rev area) and no real loss of refinement in driveability, we're easily sold on the N20-powered F10 5-series. As long, that is, as a turbocharged inline six remains in the lineup. Why? Well, even though BMW could (and probably will) get more power out of the 2.0-liter, we'd miss the character of the straight six. Luckily for us, that's not going anywhere any time soon. Bravo.

That's wrong - the first North American application for the N20 is in the (so far) Canada-exclusive X1. The N20 and the X1 are great together - it's a quick vehicle and just pulls and pulls. It actually stops and stops too - the brakes are fantastic. While it's true that it's priced very near the X3, the X1 is much quicker and sportier and is really targeted at a different audience, I think.
Sorry guys, this isn't the first BMW in North America to use the N20 engine. The X1 which is available in Canada uses this engine and it is amazing. Mated with the 8-speed automatic, this acceleration is very quick and it gets 35+ mpg on the highway. This only issue is its priced to close to the X3.
Not necessarily, the turbo components do add some weight. Probably weigh similar to their silky straight six N/A counterparts.
With the engines going smaller, the weight of the vehicles must go lower too. All of the modern cars are about 500-1,000 lbs. heavier, compared to cars of the same size in the 1960-70 era. There are also many features, which may be nice, but used very little and simplicity disappear. By the way, when less cylinders do the same or more work, they wear out faster. Of course this is not mentioned in a road test, when everyone is sitting pretty enjoying a new car. There is no replacement of a large displacement 6 or 8 cylinder engine, running slowly, nicely, smoothly, generating lots of torque.

New Car Research

our instagram

get Automobile Magazine

Subscribe to the magazine and save up to 84% off the newsstand price


new cars

Read Related Articles