After a sojourn in New York, our Four Seasons 2013 Nissan Altima returned to Michigan just in time for summer. Before the car left the East Coast, though, New York -- based senior editor Joe Lorio laid some groundwork for the next batch of comments in the Nissan's logbook.
I love commuting in this car. It's surprisingly fast with the V-6 and supremely smooth with the CVT.
"The V-6 is an intriguing option," Lorio said. "On the one hand, I can see why fewer than ten percent of Altima buyers choose it. It's expensive, adding about $2900 to the price of an SL. And you take a big hit in fuel economy, dropping 5 mpg in city ratings and 7 mpg on the EPA's highway cycle. However, gas mileage is still quite good; I regularly saw 32 mpg on the highway. The V-6 also adds 88 hp, which makes the Altima a muscular mid-sizer. The extra output also means that the CVT effectively becomes a nonissue; the whole powertrain is so much more pleasant than the four-cylinder Altima's."
Immediately upon the Nissan's Michigan homecoming, executive editor Todd Lassa took a different slant on the car's powertrain: "The V-6 option is nearly useless in a mid-size sedan that comes only with a CVT. The V-6 did, however, come in handy beating traffic on Woodward Avenue in a heavy-throttle Michigan-left launch. The front wheels wanted to steer across all three lanes, but here was the one time this bland mid-size sedan's powertrain option made sense to me. Otherwise, if I'm buying an Altima for innocuous, comfortable commutes, why wouldn't I go for the four-cylinder, with its significant bump in fuel efficiency?"
Senior web editor Phil Floraday's opinion is more in line with Lorio's: "The V-6 has way more power than anyone needs. Still, I love commuting in this car. It's surprisingly fast with the V-6, supremely smooth with the CVT, and has incredibly comfortable seats. I will happily trade driver involvement during my commute for a car that's so easy to live with each day. I still want a real driver's car on fun roads, but my daily slog is far from an ideal canyon road."
On one occasion in particular, Floraday was very pleased with the powertrain's ability to rocket past plodding traffic. "I had a hellish trip to Kalamazoo in the Altima," Floraday reported. "It was one of those typical scenes on I-94 where somebody was always poking along in the left lane at well under the speed limit. Trucks were scattered in the right lane. Rolling chicanes everywhere. Fortunately, our Altima is powered by a 270-hp V-6 and the CVT is happy to keep the engine in its powerband. I made at least three moves to the right where I passed a dozen or so sheep afraid to go around the oblivious person leading the parade. I never could have pulled off any of those passes with a car like our Four Seasons Dodge Dart, for instance. Even though the Altima has no sporty pretense, it's able to fight its way through traffic quite nicely when it has to."
During more relaxing drives, we noticed a couple of bothersome noises coming from the Altima, so we took it to the local Nissan dealership. One noise was a humming sound from the rear of the car; the other was a ticking sound from the ventilation system. Sure enough, the technicians found a bad right-rear hub bearing and debris in the cabin's air filter. They replaced the wheel bearing under warranty and removed the debris from the filter, and the sounds have disappeared. About 3000 miles earlier, that same cabin air filter had been replaced during the Altima's second scheduled service visit (the 15,000-mile checkup -- cost $141.25), so we're hoping it stays debris- and noise-free until our time with the 2013 Nissan Altima concludes in late September.