Reviews

2010 Audi S5 S-Tronic Cabriolet

The 2010 Audi S5 Cabriolet is by far the quietest softtop convertible I have ever driven. There was no howling wind noise or cold air coming through the tight seams; the S5 Cabriolet really drove like a fixed-roof vehicle. Surprisingly, the driver’s rearward visibility isn’t hindered by the top; the car has slightly larger blind spots at the C-pillars, but the lack of a B-pillar more than makes up for it. Unfortunately I didn’t get a chance to lower the top while driving due to the sub-freezing temperatures outside, but unlike other convertibles on the market, the Audi S5 Cabriolet is still a stylish ride regardless of where the top is positioned, especially in this color scheme, with brilliant red paint and a black top.

The 7-speed dual-clutch S-tronic transmission is very refined and super smooth, although the S5 felt stubborn to go when I had the steering wheel locked to one side and then pressed the gas pedal. The transmission shuttered and the steering wheel shook as the Quattro all-wheel-drive tried to pull the car out of the tight situation.

Our test unit was not equipped with a sports rear differential; but even without it, it was still a blast to drive the Audi S5 sideways down snow-covered country roads. The car is simply amazing.

Mike Ofiara, Road Test Coordinator

I’ve been hearing a lot from a certain Audi competitor about a “convertible for four seasons.” I hate to break it to them, but it will be difficult — if not impossible — to wrest such a title away from Audi’s S5.

Here, we have not only a cabriolet that’s drop-dead gorgeous, faster than a speeding bullet, and an absolute dream in winter wonderlands. The combination of this car’s Michelin snow tires and Audi’s legendary Quattro all-wheel-drive system made the S5 virtually unstoppable, even on some thick ice I encountered in a rutted, gravel parking lot.

I’m fairly happy this example was devoid of Audi’s blind-spot warning system. Not only is the driver blessed with fairly good visibility (the lack of B-pillars helps, for sure), but the warning system has a habit of creating false readings on radar detectors — and you’re going to want to use one with this car. Audi’s moving the S5 from the beefy 4.2-liter V-8 to the supercharged 3.2-liter V-6, and while I missed the timbre of the eight-cylinder motor, this new engine has plenty of thrust.

Perhaps too much thrust, in fact. Every time I merged onto a divided highway, I would soon find myself startled by the chirp of the built-in speed warning — which I set at 80 mph…

My gripes are few, but given how most Michigan winters are, I could stand for the seat warmers to err on the side of scalding. Even on their highest setting, these felt lukewarm at best. I also know Audi needs to have some sort of trim level system, but it seems odd to drive a $60,000 convertible with a manual-dimming rear-view mirror. If you want that, you’ll have to spring for the “Prestige” S5 Cabriolet, which adds an extra $5700 to the price (and also allows you to opt for the customizable Drive Select system).

Evan McCausland, Web Producer

As I drove the Audi S5 Cabriolet into work this morning over a fine dusting of snow, I couldn’t help but have the same thought as Evan. Mercedes-Benz claims its new E-class Cabriolet is the convertible for four seasons, but how can you argue with Audi’s all-wheel drive? The E-class, however, does offer Airscarf, which blows warm air onto the necks of front-seat passengers. That’s a feature I would have appreciated when I dropped the roof in 32-degree weather for my 20-minute commute down the highway. While the seat heaters and full-blast heat could hardly keep up with the Michigan weather, a thick winter jacket kept things tolerable.

Like Mike, I noticed an impressively quiet cabin at highway speeds with the top up. Audi has said it believes it can use a soft top to achieve the same comfort levels of a hard roof without the packaging and weight tradeoffs. Having driven this S5, I believe them.

The seven-speed dual-clutch transmission is excellent, and I enjoy the ability to choose from three different shift modes (normal, sport, manual). Shifts are smooth and quick, and there’s a delightful brrrwaaaapp on full-throttle upshifts. Predictably, Audi’s wildly variable steering effort continues to irk me. A lot.

Eric Tingwall, Associate Editor

I had forgotten that Audi was phasing out the V-8 in the S5 in favor of its new supercharged V-6; when I first got in the car, I was like, where’s the V-8 burble? And what’s with this quick-shifting, dual-clutch automatic transmission? And then I launched the S5 onto a freeway entrance ramp and remembered, ah, yes, the S5 now gets the same smooth and torquey supercharged V-6 as the new S4 sport sedan. Very nice, and I can live without the V-8.

So it was Evan who set the speed warning tone for only 80 mph! That thing kept dinging at me every time I dipped into the accelerator. But I was actually kind of grateful that he had set it, because otherwise I would have been driving at 100 mph the whole time without even trying.

As others have noted, the S5 is a gorgeous car, and Audi’s fabric convertible roofs are beautifully constructed and give away little to a fixed steel roof in terms of sound suppression. And the S5’s even has little LED reading lamps for the rear-seat built into the fabric roof, which are very cool.

Another powertrain note: The S5 Cabriolet is powered solely by the supercharged V-6 mated to the S Tronic transmission, but the S5 coupe still gets the V-8, mated either to a conventional automatic or a six-speed manual. So the hardcore V-8 fans still have that choice, just not with a fabric roof.

Joe DeMatio, Executive Editor

2010 Audi S5 S-Tronic Cabriolet

Base price (with destination): $59,075
Price as tested: $61,475

Standard Equipment:
3.0L supercharged 6-cylinder engine
7-speed dual clutch S tronic transmission
Quattro all-wheel-drive
19-inch alloy wheels
S5 sport suspension and brakes
Three zone climate control
Heated front seats
Bluetooth
AM/FM radio with in-dash CD player

Options on this vehicle:
Navigation package — $2400
-Navigation with 3g MMI
-Rearview camera
-Rear parking sensors
-Color driver information system

Key options not on vehicle:
Sports rear differential — $1100
Comfort package — $1400
Bang & Olufsen sound system — $850

Fuel economy:
(city/hwy/combined)
17 / 26 / 22 mpg

Engine:
Size: 3.0L Supercharged 6-cylinder
Horsepower: 333 hp @ 5500-7000 rpm
Torque: 325 lb-ft @ 2900-5300 rpm

Drive:
All-wheel

Transmission:
7-speed dual-clutch automatic S tronic

Weight: 4294 lbs

Wheels/tires:
19-inch alloy wheels
255/35R19 Michelin winter tires

Comments

We’ve Temporarily Removed Comments

As part of our ongoing efforts to make AutomobileMag.com better, faster, and easier for you to use, we’ve temporarily removed comments as well as the ability to comment. We’re testing and reviewing options to possibly bring comments back. As always, thanks for reading AutomobileMag.com.

Buying Guide
Powered by Motortrend
2010 Audi S5

2010 Audi S5

MSRP $58,250 3.0 quattro Convertible

0-60 MPH:

5 SECS

EPA MPG:

17 City / 26 Hwy

Horse Power:

333 @ 7000