Reviews

2009 BMW 135i – Four Seasons Update – February 2009

Long-Term 2009 BMW 1-Series Update: Winter 2009 Miles to date: 0

It’s February, and Michigan is enjoying one of its snowiest winters on record. The BMW 135i, unfortunately, isn’t much of a snowmobile.

Online editor Phil Floraday: “Very limited ground clearance, marginal tires, and overactive traction control means you need to forego electronic nannies and carefully choose your lines turning into parking lots or down unplowed streets. I never really got stuck (though once I did have to use the ice scraper to move some mounds of snow away from the rear tires), but I spent a lot of time worrying about that or spinning the car. I prefer to leave ESP on in the winter, but even the dynamic mode doesn’t allow for enough wheelspin to get the 135i started from a light or away from a curb. Switching the ESP all the way off takes a few seconds, so I just left it off when there was deep snow or ice around. If you are careful, the 135 is a fine car in the snow, but I’d much rather have a little extra ground clearance.”

East coast bureau chief, Jamie Kitman, manages to wrangle the 1-series away from the Ann Arbor home office, and spirit it away to New York.

Kitman: “The straight six engine is a wonderful product differentiator for BMW. It’s a wonder [almost] no one makes them when they’re so creamy smooth.

Ignoring things like my children and luggage, I’d take a 1-series over a 3-series. I like the relative lack of girth and the extra snugness, which can be a little oppressive – claustrophobic even – when you’re just puttering around, although it makes a lot of sense when you’re getting it on in the 1.

Still, in my heart of hearts, I think it is too big and heavy. Two hundred pounds less than a 3-series is not enough; Five-hundred would have been better. If it were that easy, though, I expect they would have done it already. But one step in the right direction might be a four-cylinder engine – and a turbo four for those who want to go really fast.”

Senior editor Joe Lorio is glad for the little BMW’s arrival.

Lorio: “Particularly after the string of SUVs and crossovers I’ve been in recently, the 135i feels awesome, with its M-worthy levels of power, and tight, precise steering (although BMW steering wheels rims have gotten almost comically fat lately).

Pulling up to a stoplight at the crest of a steep hill in Jamie’s riverside town, I discovered something new and, at that moment, quite welcome about this car: a hill-holder clutch. The brakes don’t let go until you hit the gas. That’s one more reason to go for the stick shift, 1-series shoppers.”

Comments
We’ve Temporarily Removed Comments

As part of our ongoing efforts to make AutomobileMag.com better, faster, and easier for you to use, we’ve temporarily removed comments as well as the ability to comment. We’re testing and reviewing options to possibly bring comments back. As always, thanks for reading AutomobileMag.com.