The Misery Index: Top 10 States with the Most Expensive Driving Costs

2012-honda-accord-ex-l-v-6-front-view

Gas and car insurance can be expensive, but how do driving costs in your state compare to those in other states? That's what a new report from CarInsurance.com attempts to find out by detailing the states with the highest gas and insurance costs along with an "Automotive Misery Index," which takes a look at the geographical cost variables in car ownership.

Using a 2012 Honda Accord EX as a base car, the index compares the cost of gas, number of miles driven, and the price of insurance coverage for all 50 states. While Wyoming drivers may spend more money on gas and insurance according to CarInsurance.com, as a percentage of the average household income, it doesn’t compare on the Misery Index to other states like West Virginia and Mississippi.

On the other side of the list are states like New Hampshire and Alaska, both of which earn placement on the Top 10 list of the least expensive to maintain (gas and insurance costs). On average, the report found the U.S. drivers travel 14,133 miles in their cars each year and have a Misery Index of 7.0 percent. Find your state here.

Top 10 states with the highest gas and insurance costs, according to CarInsurance.com:

Rank  State  Gas & Insurance  Income  Misery Index
51  Mississippi  $4,277  $36,821  11.6%
50  Oklahoma  $4,816  $45,018  10.7%
49  Louisiana  $4,504  $42,813  10.5%
48  West Virginia  $4,292  $41,999  10.2%
47  Montana  $4,005  $41,286  9.7%
46  Georgia  $4,268  $44,082  9.7%
45  Michigan  $4,274  $46,597  9.2%
44  Wyoming  $4,828  $52,848  9.1%
43  Kentucky  $3,860  $42,302  9.1%
42  Arkansas  $3,411  $37,856  9.0%
Top 10 states with the least expensive gas and insurance costs, according to CarInsurance.com
Rank  State  Gas & Insurance  Income  Misery Index
1  New Hampshire  $2,932  $65,948  4.4%
2  Alaska  $2,765  $60,409  4.6%
3  Connecticut  $3,266  $66,187  4.9%
4  Colorado  $2,955  $58,647  5.0%
5  Washington  $2,976  $58,821  5.1%
6  Massachusetts  $3,087  $60,843  5.1%
7  New Jersey  $3,301  $64,693  5.1%
8  Maryland  $3,347  $64,635  5.2%
9  Virginia  $3,412  $60,931  5.6%
10  Utah  $3,314  $58,122  5.7%
For more on new car vehicle costs, view our features covering the top 10 cheapest and most expensive cars and minivans to insure for the 2012 model year.

Source: CarInsurance.com

Rank  State  Gas & Insurance  Income  Misery Index
51  Mississippi  $4,277  $36,821  11.6%
50  Oklahoma  $4,816  $45,018  10.7%
49  Louisiana  $4,504  $42,813  10.5%
48  West Virginia  $4,292  $41,999  10.2%
47  Montana  $4,005  $41,286  9.7%
46  Georgia  $4,268  $44,082  9.7%
45  Michigan  $4,274  $46,597  9.2%
44  Wyoming  $4,828  $52,848  9.1%
43  Kentucky  $3,860  $42,302  9.1%
42  Arkansas  $3,411  $37,856  9.0%
Rank  State  Gas & Insurance  Income  Misery Index
1  New Hampshire  $2,932  $65,948  4.4%
2  Alaska  $2,765  $60,409  4.6%
3  Connecticut  $3,266  $66,187  4.9%
4  Colorado  $2,955  $58,647  5.0%
5  Washington  $2,976  $58,821  5.1%
6  Massachusetts  $3,087  $60,843  5.1%
7  New Jersey  $3,301  $64,693  5.1%
8  Maryland  $3,347  $64,635  5.2%
9  Virginia  $3,412  $60,931  5.6%
10  Utah  $3,314  $58,122  5.7%
John
Oklahoma is AWFUL. Their gas has so much ethanol in it that my guel mileage drops by 15%. I filled up in Ohio though and my car went from 28-31mpg maximum to 35mpg. And I know I am not calculating wrong because I got nearly 450 miles from a tank of gas and that is way out of bounds.

buyer's guide

Find vehicle reviews, photos, & pricing

our instagram

get Automobile Magazine

Subscribe to the magazine and save up to 84% off the newsstand price

subscribe

new cars

Read Related Articles

TO TOP