Your browser, , is out of date and not supported by www.automobilemag.com. It may not display all features of our site properly and could have potential security flaws. Please update your browser to the most upated version. Update Now
Close x
automobilemag.com
Home / New Cars / Porsche / 911 / 2009 911 / Reviews / Nissan GT-R, Mazdaspeed 3, Chevrolet Corvette Z06, Mitsubishi Lancer Evo, Pontiac G8 GT - Giant Killers

Nissan GT-R, Mazdaspeed 3, Chevrolet Corvette Z06, Mitsubishi Lancer Evo, Pontiac G8 GT - Giant Killers

Research the 2009 Porsche 911

Go
Porsche 911 Turbo vs. Nissan GT-R
By Don Sherman
The Nissan GT-R,Japan's most earnest attempt to build a supercar capable of smiting the European standard-bearers, isn't perfect, but the savings over a Porsche 911 Turbo will easily cover a Boxster. True confessions: I never met a Porsche I didn't like. And, with personal experience stretching from the 1975 launch of the original 911 Turbo past the 2004 Carrera GT, my all-time personal fave, I've met more than my share of Stuttgart specials. Marque passions aside, it's clear to me that Nissan's brand-new GT-R is quicker, faster, and a better value than Porsche's iconic 911 Turbo. While the stats back me up, this row goes beyond zero-to-ticket acceleration figures and which sports car does the better job hustling through corners. This is the title bout for the near-200-mph supercar crown. This is where Godzilla stomps in from the Orient to slap Porsche's $127,060 prize fighter with its killer tail. On paper, the protagonists seem so alike. Each has the identical number of horses, cylinders, turbos, gears, and driven wheels (four). Nissan's GT-R project manager, Kazutoshi Mizuno, obviously scrutinized his enemy in intimate detail. What's amazing is how much his team got wrong. In my book, the perfect sports car wouldn't lounge on a 109.5-inch wheelbase, require six driveshafts, have its engine plopped atop its front axle, or crowd two tons at weigh-in. Give the GT-R points for succeeding in spite of itself. So how can the GT-R thumb flame-snorting nostrils at my principles and be so entertaining to drive? It's because Mizuno-san never had the slightest intention of creating the ideal sports car. The mission he accomplished was to nudge aside an elderly icon to clear a spot for the most exciting ride you can buy for less than $100,000. Allow me to define exciting. It's the sound of a feral V-6 rattling windows and rousing neighbors every time its chain is tugged. It's a suspension that's locked and ready to lap the Nordschleife when you are. It's exterior design so intentionally at odds with classic beauty and refined taste that the GT-R's wake is a continuous mess of dropped jaws, twisted necks, and pointing fingers. Where other cars have exhaust pipes, this one has five-inch howitzers. Excitement is a video-game interior with enough switches and screens to reprogram the most devout e-hater into a Super Mario game boy. It's a shopping cart overflowing with so much carbon fiber, forged aluminum, and NACA ducting that Mizuno-san deserves the SAE's highest commendation. The GT-R beats the 911 Turbo by skipping traditional virtues. The Nissan rump badge is negative cachet. Couth is not part of the package. The GT-R's cockpit is an endless cavalcade of clanking gears, rattling shafts, whirring tires, and booming exhaust serenades. The "comfort" setting for the adjustable dampers and the 480-hp rating are two blatant lies. I hate the piggish, tire-chunking understeer hiding at the GT-R's cornering limit. Only the Japanese would engineer a four-wheel-drive car that spins its rear tires when you pull the launch trigger. I forgive these sins because the GT-R's paddleshifted dual-clutch automatic is such a ready source of entertainment. The other thing I love about the GT-R is the sharp stinger it pokes in Porsche's eye. How long do you think Stuttgart will sit back and allow the GT-R to surpass the 911 Turbo at the Nürburgring? Answer: not long.

Subscribe & Save

Subscribe & Save

Thank you for visiting [SiteName1]

You’ve been redirected to Automobile Magazine, part of the same Source Interlink Media network of sites as [SiteName2]. Automobile Magazine has more in-depth new car content that we believe will be more beneficial for you. Feel free to contact us with any feedback.
-The Source Interlink Media Team

Close SIM Automotive